X and containment few issues in recent years lhave been more lhotly contested in the hiistorical professioln than the origins of the cold war, and few cold war documents have been more controversial than george f. We cannot forget that massive nuclear stockpiles threaten civilization and the planets ecosystem. Columnist walter lippmann attacked the xarticle for failing to differentiate between vital and peripheral interests. Archives records through ongoing lectures, monthly. Kennan attempted to fight back against the misunderstanding of this article by focusing on politicaleconomic policies, but it became clear. Kennan writes to the secretary of state with a lengthy.
The historian john lewis gaddis, author of a 2012 pulitzer prizewinning biography of george kennan, has stated that the mudd library holds the most significant set of papers for the study of modern american history outside of federal hands. Find all the books, read about the author, and more. Jul 27, 2019 state department official george kennan, using the pseudonym mr. Nov, 2009 george kennan, the american charge daffaires in moscow, sends an 8,000word telegram to the department of state detailing his views on the soviet union, and u. The article was signed by x although everyone in the know knew that authorship was kennan s. Apr, 2012 in 1946, kennan was 44 years old, fluent in the russian language and its affairs, and decidedly anticommunist. In 1946, kennan was 44 years old, fluent in the russian language and its affairs, and decidedly anticommunist. In july 1947, the quarterly foreign affairs published an anonymous article entitled the sources of soviet conduct, which offered what would soon. Historians consider this article the most significant public explanation of americas.
In july 1947, george frost kennan, us ambassador to moscow, anonymously publishes in the us journal foreign affairs a damning indictment of soviet international policy and diplomatic practices. The sources of soviet conduct from foreign affairs july 1947 caption. Shortly thereafter, the identity of the author, x, was revealed as george frost kennan, then the new director of the state departments policy planning staff. The sources of soviet conduct from foreign affairs july 1947. George kennan is still the russia expert america needs. But kennan had in mind more than the containment while this article appeared anonymously under the a. George kennan x, the sources of soviet conduct, july 1947. State department official george kennan, using the pseudonym mr. The main element of any united states policy toward the soviet union must be a longterm, patient but firm and vigilant containment of russian expansive tendencies.
When he died, one hundred and one years later, there were about two hundred and eighty million. X, publishes an article entitled the sources of soviet conduct in the july edition of foreign affairs. Formally titled the sources of soviet conduct, the x article appeared in the july 1947 issue of foreign affairs magazine. The sales job worked, of course, setting an example mimicked ever since by the. He has spent the second half of his life explaining away his x article, apologizing for its excessively militaristic ring and lamenting the uses to which it was put.
This article uses the relationship between george kennan and dean acheson as a lens to track a classic debate over the main lines of postwar american foreign policy, especially in regard to europe and over such related issues as negotiations with the soviets, german unification, and the size of and necessity for american conventional and nuclear forces. The article was signed with an x because kennan did not want it to seem that, as a state department employee, he was stating policy, but his identity was quickly revealed, and for the rest. The collected columns were republished that year as a book lippmann 1947. Developed in the pseudonymous x article in the july issue of foreign affairs in 1947, kennan s thesis boiled down to four propositions i that moscow, for various historical, ideological and geographical reasons, was a regime defined by its deep insecurity and thus in.
Whats old is new kennan, putin, and the russian competitive viewpoint november 30, 2015 lieutenant colonel michael a. Kennans views on containment were elucidated in a famous and highly influential article, signed x, that appeared in foreign affairs magazine for july 1947, analyzing in detail the structure and psychology of soviet diplomacy. Kennans essay is often said to be the most influential article in the history of this countrys foreign policy, but neither harry truman, nor any president after him, actually followed xs. X article on soviet union appears in foreign affairs.
Kennan first outlined that strategy in a confidential dispatch he sent from the u. Dec 22, 2016 george kennan is still the russia expert america needs. The sources of soviet conduct was originally published by an author x although many knew the author was george keenan. The article was considered monumental and its author, though a mystery at first, to be a firstrate interpreter of soviet intentions in the postwwii. This may be true, but is often only relevant to researchers who have the resources to access them. A 1978 critique of gaddis on kennan history news network. George kennan, the containment doctrine, and isis by john r. Project muse containment and the primacy of diplomacy. When this book is published i fear that to the vast majority of americans his name will be unknown. The sources of soviet conduct, an essay pseudonymously published in foreign affairs in 1947, better known as the x article.
George kennan, the american charge daffaires in moscow, sends an 8,000word telegram to the department of state detailing his views on the soviet union, and u. Kennan would be dispatched to prague in 193839, in time to witness hitlers annihilation of czechoslovakia. His conclusion was that the main element of any united states policy toward the soviet union must be that of a longterm patient but firm and vigilant containment of russian expansive tendencies. George kennan sends long telegram to state department. Kennans policy was controversial from the very beginning. Soviet pressure against the free institutions of the western world is something that can be contained by the adroit and vigilant application of counterforce x george f. Kennan and the vietnam war, 19501968 randall doyle grand valley state university. Kennan would be dispatched to prague in 193839, in time to. Few in the west had experience with the communist state and even fewer understood what motivated the soviets. George kennan and containment short history department. In july 1947, george frost kennan, us ambassador to.
Haines is a senior fellow of the foreign policy research institute and executive director of fpris. X, published an outline of his philosophy in the prestigious journal foreign affairs in 1947. Brian diemert bio unless you are at home in the metaphor, unless you have had your proper poetical education in the metaphor, you are not safe anywhere. Xs aim was not to educate or enlighten but to manipulate and sell. Entitled the sources of soviet conduct, this article was published anony mously in. The sources of soviet conduct from foreign affairs july.
The x article, formally titled the sources of soviet conduct, was an article written by george f. To print a pdf, you must first download the file and open it in a pdf viewer. The sources of soviet conduct, life, july 28, 1947, 5363. The x article took the information presented in the two prior reports and constructed a road map for the cold war.
Kennan had entered the diplomatic service the year after graduating from princeton, and gone on to serve at the embassy in moscow after franklin roosevelt had granted diplomatic recognition to the ussr in 1933. Kennan writes to the secretary of state with a lengthy analysis of soviet policy in an attempt to explain their recent uncooperative behavior. At the end of the war, the soviet union was a closed society under the iron grip of joseph stalin. The sources of soviet conduct byx the political personality of soviet power as we know it to day is the product of ideology and circumstances. X to avoid any charge that he was presenting official u. George kennan sends long telegram to state department history.
That was a reality kennan understood and reagan came to grasp. When foreign affairs, the influential establishment outlet sponsored by the council on foreign relations, wanted to celebrate the thirtieth anniversary of kennans famous 1947 x article in. Conference participants frank costigliola, university of connecticut frank costigliola is a professor of history at the university of connecticut. The interpretation situates kennan as the impractical, even if ultimately prescient, dreamer, because after 1949 he consistently argued for reengaging the soviets with serious diplomacy. X article on soviet union appears in foreign affairs history. Negotiating access through gatekeepers, securing parental consent and limits on confidentiality are central issues in the recruitment process of children. Developed in the pseudonymous xarticle in the july issue of foreign affairs in 1947, kennans thesis boiled down to four propositions i that moscow, for various historical, ideological and geographical reasons, was a regime defined by its deep insecurity and thus in. George kennans long telegram, february 22, 1946, history and public policy. Only by looking at the origins of the x article and by placing it in the context of his other writings and lectures of the time can kennans understanding of the soviet problem, the ultimate significance of the cold war, and his recommendations about diplomatic and military measures be fully grasped. The article was signed by x although everyone in the know knew that authorship was kennans. Kennan, who was the deputy chief of mission of the united states to the ussr from 1944 to 1946, advocated in the article a policy of containment of the soviet union and strong anticommunism. Kennan was a career diplomat with extensive service abroad as well as in washington. In 1945 the united states saw the soviet union as its principal ally.
The sources of soviet conduct byx the political personality of soviet power as we know it today is the product of ideology and circumstances. George kennan, the subject of todays program, was probably the most prominent russia and soviet specialist of his day. In the article kennan, who drew heavily from his long telegram, questioned the wisdom of the united states attempts to conciliate and appease the soviet union. Meanwhile, it was soon revealed informally that x was indeed kennan. Only by looking at the origins of the x article and by placing it in the context of his other writings and lectures of the time can kennans. The essence of kennans telegram was published in foreign affairs in 1947 as the sources of soviet conduct and circulated everywhere. The united states, kennans article implied, should face down the soviet union and its communist allies whenever and wherever they posed a risk of gaining influence. He repeated it in an article, the sources of soviet conduct, that he published under the pseudonym mr. As the first director of the policy planning staff in the department of state, he played a seminal role in the crafting of. One man who had first hand knowledge was a foreign service officer, george f. Kennan became trapped by the x article, as it distorted his views, making it appear that he was contradicting his original approach to containment. The political personality of soviet power as we know it today is the product of ideology and circumstances. George kennans long telegram, february 22, 1946, history and public policy program digital archive, national archives and records administration, department of state records record group 59, central decimal file, 19451949, 861.
Accessing a hard to reach population of children can, however, raise significant ethical and methodological challenges for researchers. The political personality of soviet power as we know it today. Soviet pressure against the free institutions of the western world is something. Lippman rebutted kennans famous x article with a series of fourteen columns published serially in the new york herald tribune from 2 september through 2 october 1947. X and published in foreign affairs magazine in july 1947. Haines is a senior fellow of the foreign policy research institute and executive director of fpris princeton committee. George kennan x, the sources of soviet conduct, july. By 1947, it saw the soviet union as its principal opponent. In 1947 he had been tapped to head the state departments new policy planning staff, which was to provide longrange analyses and plans for the conduct of american foreign relations. But george kennan neither predicted nor advocated a military victory, not even one that rested on a spending race and the demonstration of superior technological prowess. George kennan s long telegram, february 22, 1946, history and public policy program digital archive, national archives and records administration, department of state records record group 59, central decimal file, 19451949, 861. He is the author, most recently, of roosevelts lost alliances princeton, 2012 and he is currently editing the diaries of george f. The article focused on kennans call for a policy of. Diplomat george kennans views long telegram of 1946 said russian leaders historically had neurotic worldview.
Formally titled the sources of soviet conduct, the xarticle appeared in the july 1947 issue of foreign affairs magazine. Subject in july 1947, george frost kennan, us ambassador to moscow, anonymously publishes in the us journal foreign affairs a damning indictment of soviet international policy and diplomatic practices. George kennan 19042005 was one of the most distinguished american diplomats of the twentieth century, and his article the sources of soviet conduct 1947 is one of the most influential documents in american diplomatic history. As charge daffaires in the american embassy in moscow, he was singularly well placed to observe and assess the soviet leadership, particularly because he.
996 962 1197 1621 354 739 426 140 484 20 1266 644 1235 1560 145 1625 439 1333 1040 83 171 441 1616 691 1066 747 1494 1401 265 869 1093 108 1062 660 703 1458